TOPIC: Wife/GF/SO Girth thread Continuation

Some very good research here - you guys really have a good thing going here.

PMMA someday soon wrote: I read somewhere that 7.5 x 5.5 was the most popular dildo size amongst women purchasing from sex shops.

That's actually quite pleasant to hear/read because a woman would still have to be holding the dildo which means she's only inserting 4-5" of actual length (similar to how long porn stars experience "dry Dick" because they can't/don't insert all the way). Perhaps a reassuring thing to note for us shorter guys

stillwantmore wrote: I find it difficult to believe the 5" Girth was voted "best". My experience as I've grown my Girth has been in fact that the bigger I get, the better response. I think women tend to be MODEST in public.

Or this could be attributed to what most women are used to in general. If the average hovers between 4.5-5.5", then most women are likely to have experienced it and can relate to the size. I suspect many inexperienced women among the group were least likely to realize the significance of Girth beyond what they have already been accustomed to, thus making them ignorant of the advantages of larger Girth. Just a guess.

4.5-5.5 is average Girth?!

Damn that was the one thing I had going for me!

On a more serious note did you read the private message I sent you S.O?

Cheers!

Did they discuss their choices with others or choose privately? I wonder if there would be a difference between women asked to state their preference in front of a crowd and another in which they choose anonymously.

@Justabitmore ' I know she wants to get over 100 responses to make it a meaningful study. She has hooked up with this girl who does the 'toy parties' with 4 or 5 other groups of women so she hopes to get data that way.I did offer to be a live 'test size model' at their upcoming events but all I got was an orange thrown at me for my kind offer!

Will update with more data as she collects it.

I find it difficult to believe the 5" Girth was voted "best". My experience as I've grown my Girth has been in fact that the bigger I get, the better response. I think women tend to be MODEST in public.

@KFH
Pardon the range, perhaps closer to 4.5" - 5.0" though can't say for certain any study on the matter is conclusive/accurate. This is coming from scouring PE forums over the years (another horrible point of reference for size lol).
And as for your PM, yes I have received it and your request is on my list of to-do's. I had been occupied with relatives for a bit and my inbox(es) have been slow to get responses. I'll make sure your request is satisfied by the end of this weekend.
Cheers

virgin_age_29 wrote: Did they discuss their choices with others or choose privately? I wonder if there would be a difference between women asked to state their preference in front of a crowd and another in which they choose anonymously.

They recorded their votes anonymously on pre-printed ballots. According to my GF there was discussion after but no identification of who voted for what.While a lot of guys need to believe it makes a big difference, the consensus for this group of women seems to be that within a broad range it's all the same.

I think the best test for Girth size may be the following: Some how (may be a woman who is willing to have sex with two different guys at the same time but she can't see their faces or bodies) have a woman have sex with a 4.5 Inch Girth penis or dildo, now have the same woman have sex with a 6 Inch Girth penis/dildo....I almost guarantee she will like the 6 Inch better! one has to take all other variables out of the experiment.

@ eq

That's great EQ! well done for a really cool effort. My wife and I did something similar and 5.5 was her max (albeit she is not exactly complaining now but I think at this stage she couldn't really care if I had 5.5 or 6 plus.

Again brilliant idea and can't wait for your girlfriends paper!

Second meet on Sunday evening. There were 25 women in attendance between the ages of 28 and 50. They dropped the 3.5' unit for this meet and used 5 dildo's all same length and asked the club members to rank them as to 'Which would be the ideal size for your mate'. The results are as follows:Length Girth Votes
8' smaller 0
8' 4.0' 0
8' 4.5' 2
8' 5.0' 12
8' 5.5' 9
8' 6.0' 1
8' larger 1 According to my GF there was more discussion before the voting amongst this group than the first group. This may have influenced the voting more than with the first group.Cumulative Totals (to date) of 43 womenLength Girth Votes
8' smaller 0
8' 4.0' 1
8' 4.5' 5
8' 5.0' 21
8' 5.5' 13
8' 6.0' 2
8' larger 1

@ HA HA HA kudos for trying though!!

I read somewhere that 7.5 x 5.5 was the most popular dildo size amongst women purchasing from sex shops.

@ eq

I second that and think its entirely true. I can now also verify for certain that my wife feels a little difference between 5.6 form before and my 6.4 now! seriously she like it it does feel bigger but she (and I trust her 100% percent) thinks there is no difference for her in terms of pleasure.

I was 5 before PE and when I got to 5.5 she loved the difference now that I am 0.9 bigger she still loves it but wouldn't care if I went back to 5.5 !!

I however love it more lol